Eddy’s Sports Pub

Reviews

• Christopher A.

  star star star star_border star_border 31 May 2026

  Checked this place out for lunch! If you want cheap bar food and cheap drinks this is for you!
  
  The food was not good at all. Ordered the buffalo burger and then wanted fries instead of their chips and was charged for those as well. The chips were terrible and so was the burger. Dry and hardly any flavor.
  
  I left feeling super unsatisfied. The only reason i didnt give this place a one star was because of the amazing service!
  
  Wont be back for the food but maybe cheap drinks!

• Cathy M.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 30 May 2026

  My husband had been to Pepper's, now Eddy's, twice and described their smoked wings as the best he's ever had!  He's generally not a fan of wings but I am, so I wanted to check these out. When we arrived, around 6:30 on a Friday night there were only a few guests. We waited a minute or two then seated ourselves. When the bartender brought menus and asked for our drink orders I asked for a drink menu which they didn't have. But my husband ordered a Margarita so I did too. When it came it was tasteless - needed more lime and something sweet. But they didn't have simple syrup and I forgot to suggest Triple Sec, which is often in Margaritas so he added Rose's Bottled lime something or another. Then I tasted it and added 2 packets of sugar that were on the bar. Then it was drinkable but not overly sweet. When I ordered my Buffalo wings I asked if I could have all flats (I'm used to Buffalo Wild Wings where you can specify). But they don't do that - they only do the whole wings cut into halves. But when they came I had only 3 flats and 7 drumettets which was not what was promised. But I would have eaten the drumettes had they not been tough and kind of gamey. But he did bring me the missing flats and they were very good. My husband ordered the smoked wings as he had on past visits. They were over cooked and did not live up to his fond memories but he ate them without complaint because that's who he is.
  
  I am giving Eddy's one star instead of none because they didn't skimp on the liquor in my drink. There's the silver lining I guess. But I would have preferred just some good friendly customer service. That may have made me willing to go back.

• Richard P.

  star star star star star_border 28 May 2026

  A couple weeks ago, I was driving through the Fort Ben area and noticed that Peppers at the Fort, a bar and grill in the area that had been maybe most known for the double-decker bus that sat in its parking lot, had shut down. In its place, Eddy's Sports Pub had a bright sign and a strong presence - sadly, no double-decker bus.
  
  While I'd hoped to get by a little more quickly, life during this holiday season got in the way and it was only on this first day of a four-day weekend that I found myself looking for a new place to snag a new Yelp review.
  
  While Eddy's does not appear to have a website nor a Facebook presence at this point, I stumbled across a page for Eddy's Sports Pub located in Noblesville. I quickly read through their feed and realized that, yes, this is their second location and it's still early into its opening.
  
  If you know this spot, then you also know that the building has had quite the tenant turnover over the past year with Subway, Great Clips, and now Peppers all leaving the building. Subway and Great Clips actually stayed in the same neighborhood, but moved to a different building. Fortunately, Eddy's took over the Peppers spot pretty quickly.
  
  If you're in a wheelchair, as I am, then you're better off parking in front of Jack's Donuts as that's where there's two accessible spots and a worn but functional curb cut. Eddy's is on the east end of the building with their entry a double-glass door that has a dividing wall. To your right, you'll see a game area - pool tables, darts, a few tables, etc. To your left, you'll see mostly 4-top tables . Sort of in the middle, you'll see a decent-sized bar area. As I was arriving outside the lunch hour and in the early afternoon, I was not surprised to see the primary server/bartender at the bar serving customers.
  
  All of the tables seem to work for wheelchairs. The chairs are a tad heavy, but the server came by fairly quickly and ended up moving the chair out of the way.
  
  There are wide-screen televisions that wrap around the bar and are also along the walls. I believe I also saw an electronic jukebox. The room was surprisingly spacious. I definitely thought it was a better atmosphere than Peppers had offered.
  
  I was pleased that they offer unsweetened iced tea. The menu seems to consist primarily of the usual bar n' grill type foods with appetizers, sandwiches and, of course, the full bar. They offer up daily specials that are easily seen on a wall.
  
  I ordered a hand-breaded tenderloin sandwich, you can also get it grilled, which comes on a toasted bun with one of a handful of sides. I opted for homemade chips. This runs $8.49 - it's $2 extra if you want to upgrade to fries or onion rings. Most sandwiches seemed to be in this ballpark price range.
  
  My server, Britt G., was super friendly. She was pretty darn efficient, especially when you consider that she was also working the bar. I did get an iced tea refill - I will admit that I lingered for a few minutes after paying and was a little bothered that another refill wasn't offered. Other than this minor issue, Britt was super and the main reason this rating is a 4 instead of a 3.
  
  The tenderloin was in the 3-3.5 range. The sandwich was good-sized, though the bun was unevenly toasted and this impacted the overall taste of the sandwich. I liked it, but didn't love it. I doubt I would order it again, but I also certainly wouldn't have complained. In fact, I have a friend who writes a tenderloin blog and I did recommend he check the place out.
  
  The homemade chips were solid and a decent-sized order. The entire plate was definitely a decent meal for just under $12 without tip.
  
  The atmosphere is warm. Country music was on in the background and I found the atmosphere encouraged conversation. There was one party of three men who were louder than they needed to be, but it's really not a bar experience if you don't have that one drunk whose voice always gets louder in the bar.
  
  While I never had a desire to return to Peppers, I'll definitely return to Eddy's. I'll likely opt for a burger or other sandwich the next time around. While they don't have a website or social media presence yet that I've seen, hopefully that arrives in the near future.

• Colby H.

  star star star star star 17 May 2026

  This place needs some props. I'm here now on a Thursday after work at 6:30 for dinner since I just moved over to this side of town and don't have groceries yet. One group of guys sitting down being chill, another 3 at a table, and 3 at the bar where I sat. Laid back, listening to back to back Queen songs now, talking to Brad my new favorite bartender, and drinking a damn good drink. Got the Buffalo Burger which is a fried beef patty with buffalo sauce and bleu cheese crumbles. Good but the house chips are best I've had ever, crispy and enough salt to be perfect. Wednesdays are poker night, Thursday nights karaoke at 10, Fridays they have a DJ, Saturdays are live music, and Brad told me Sundays they are looking to do a Latin night possibly. Pool tables, darts, Golden Tee, and a ton of tvs. Great place.

• Alora G.

  star star star star star 16 May 2026

  Friendly and a good place to relax after work.
  Always have drinks specials and appetizer specials from 3 PM to 5 PM.
  Best known for their house smoke wings, they have a range of sauces to choose from; their burgers and chicken strips are delish also!
  My favorite is that they have the best sides, house-made kettle chips, salted fries, waffle fries, and onion petals.
  
  With a full bar, TVs everywhere, pool tables, jukebox, bands on the weekends - can't go wrong with popping in and checking it out :)